New Jersey’s highest-ranking Catholic Church leader, Cardinal Joseph Tobin, announced on Monday that he has commissioned a comprehensive third-party review of the 2019 investigation into sexual abuse at Seton Hall University involving its current president, Monsignor Joseph Reilly.
Background of the Investigation
Despite not being directly accused of abuse, Monsignor Joseph Reilly faced scrutiny in 2019 after an investigation revealed that he had knowledge of sexual abuse allegations but failed to report them appropriately. The investigation was conducted by the law firm Latham & Watkins following allegations against former Cardinal Theodore McCarrick.
New Review by Ropes & Gray
Cardinal Tobin has now engaged the services of the firm Ropes & Gray to delve into the specifics of the Latham & Watkins report and the overall investigation. This review will also assess the implementation of the Responsive Action Plan that Seton Hall University adopted based on the previous findings.
Transparency and Cooperation
In a statement, Cardinal Tobin emphasized the importance of a transparent review process involving all relevant parties, including the Board of Regents and Seton Hall University. The review will focus on how the investigation findings were communicated and handled within the university and the Archdiocese.
While no specific timeline has been set for the review, Cardinal Tobin has underscored the need for a comprehensive and unbiased examination of the facts to address the concerns raised by various stakeholders.
Support for Monsignor Reilly
Seton Hall University has stood by Monsignor Joseph Reilly amidst the controversy, with Board of Regents Chair Hank D’Alessandro defending him against recent criticisms. However, calls for Monsignor Reilly’s resignation have emerged from state lawmakers, urging the university to release its internal report on the matter.
Past Investigations and Findings
Previous investigations at Seton Hall University uncovered a history of sexual harassment and a culture of fear during Cardinal Theodore McCarrick’s tenure. The university has been urged to address these findings and ensure accountability moving forward.
Looking Towards Resolution
Cardinal Tobin’s commitment to transparency and accountability in dealing with past abuse cases reflects a broader effort within the Catholic Church to restore trust and uphold its mission of spiritual guidance and support.